Should You Consider Higher Deductibles?

We know that costs on everything have gone up recently, including home and auto insurance. If you are looking for ways to save, I would highly recommend increasing your deductibles on your home and auto policies.

I know years ago I raised my deductibles. I raised my auto insurance deductible from $500 to $1000 and saved $700 per year over the past five years. I did have a deer claim and hated writing the larger check for that, but I reminded myself I had saved $3500 over the past five years.

Increasing your home insurance deductible from $1000 to $2500 can save you about 13% each year. I personally would not turn in a small claim that would be worth less than $2500 on my home insurance anyways. Remember, a claim is a claim, no matter how small.

For home insurance, it may several years to break even. For example, increasing your deductible from $1000 to $2500 means you would have to pay $1500 more than before if you had a claim. However, say your premium is now $300 less per year due to selecting the higher deductible. After 5 years, you would have spent that $1500 ($300 per year x 5 years) on your premium, so now if you had a claim you would be spending the same amount, it just comes out as a deductible. The good thing is if you don’t have a claim, you get to keep this money.

On auto insurance, most people are choosing $1000 deductibles versus $500, which usually can break even in one to two years. Again, the encouragement is to not turn in small claims.

Insurance companies really want all of us to have more skin in the game, and taking a higher deductible means we are taking on a little bit of the financial responsibility of that risk ourselves. This guide goes into more detail on What Policyholders Need to Know About Home & Auto Insurance.

Another thing to think about, if you have access to professionals in an auto body shop or handymen for home repairs, you can probably hire them at a lower cost  than what is charged to an insurance company, so you don’t have to turn in a claim for smaller things.

This may also be the time to set up an emergency fund, if you have not already. That way, when you need your deductible, it’s sitting in an account and you’re not caught short.

We would be happy to review all your policies to see how we can help you reduce your cost by increasing your deductibles.

In case you missed it – we have created a guide on What Policyholders Need to Know About Home & Auto Insurance. 

We hope this information helps you to make more strategic insurance decisions. We’d love to hear from you – please reach out! We are here to help.

Check out more resources on personal insurance!

SIGN UP TO RECEIVE EMAILS HERE

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • This field is hidden when viewing the form

More Posts

Peace of Mind Starts with Preparation: My Top Tips for Protecting Yourself and Your Car During Storm Season

As Thanksgiving approaches, I want to take a moment to express my heartfelt gratitude. Thank you for trusting me—and our entire OneDigital team—to help protect what matters most to you and your family. It’s truly an honor to serve you. With the holiday season upon us, it’s also a good time to think about preparation—especially when it comes to staying safe on the road. Whether it’s a surprise thunderstorm or an icy November morning, a

Preparing Your Home for Severe Weather

Preparing Your Home for Severe WeatherSevere weather rarely gives us a heads-up. One moment the skies are calm, and the next, the wind is howling and rain is pounding against the windows. Over the years, I’ve heard from countless homeowners who wished they’d had just a little more time—or taken a few extra steps—before the storm rolled in. That’s why preparation matters. With the right precautions, you can protect not only your home, but also

Cyber Crimes & Kindness: When Being Helpful Costs You $30,000

Let’s talk about something that’s becoming all too common in today’s digital world: cyber crimes. Not the Hollywood-style hacking with green code raining down the screen, but the sneaky, manipulative kind that preys on good-hearted people who just want to help. Recently, one of my clients—an intelligent, thoughtful person—was taken for $30,000. Why? Because they wanted to be helpful. That’s it. No reckless clicking, no shady websites. Just a desire to do the right thing.

A Summer Journey and the Importance of Teen Driving Safety

I hope you’re finding ways to stay cool during this record-breaking summer heat! My family and I just wrapped up a 2,000-mile road trip that took us from celebrating my granddaughter’s 6th birthday in Florida to marking my son-in-law’s 40th in North Carolina. It was a trip full of laughter, love, and plenty of miles, along with a fair share of heavy traffic and unpredictable weather. Clearly, we weren’t the only ones traveling this summer.